Jessica Ridgeway was a 10-year-old child from Westminster, Colorado. On the morning of October 5, 2012, she was abducted while walking to school by 17-year-old Austin Sigg. Jessica was later murdered in his home. Her remains were subsequently disposed of along a rural roadway, where they were later found by investigators.

What really happens inside a jury room during an attempted murder trial?

This week, Juror #1 breaks their silence — and their story will change how you see justice forever.

Behind Paranoid Sisters is Paul — the steady presence behind the scenes and husband to Sam, one half of the Paranoid Sisters team. Known as the unofficial “calm in the chaos,” Paul keeps things grounded while Sam dives headfirst into true crime’s darkest corners. When he’s not supporting the show, he’s likely knee-deep in a fishing spot chasing the perfect cast, or breaking down a football game with full analyst-level commentary (requested or not). Loyal, patient, and rock-solid, Paul balances the intensity of true crime with a love for open water, good competition, and showing up for the people who matter most.

Former CBI DNA analyst Yvonne “Missy” Woods is accused of manipulating DNA data across more than 1,000 cases over 15 years. What began as a missing value in one file unraveled into 102 felony charges, wrongful convictions, shaken survivors, and a justice system scrambling to rebuild trust.

Fort Collins, 1987. Peggy Hettrick is found murdered in a field. A teenage boy is blamed - without proof. Decades later, DNA clears him and a forensic analyst's dark secret brings the case full circle.

Five days before Christmas in 1984, 12-year-old Jonelle Matthews vanished from her Colorado home, leaving only footprints in the snow — and decades of unanswered questions. Thirty-five years later, a shocking discovery exposed a name long hiding in plain sight. Join Sam and Phalisia as they unravel one of Colorado’s most haunting cold cases.

On November 19, 2022, a gunman opened fire inside Club Q - one of Colorado Springs' only LGBTQ+ nightclubs - killing five and injuring dozens. The shooting, later ruled a hate crime, exposed years of ignored red flags and system failures. Amid the chaos, heroes like Richard Fierro and Thomas James fought back, saving lives and turning a night of hate into one of unimaginable courage and resilience.

Sam & Phalisia return with updates on three shocking Colorado cases: Barry Morphew, newly re-indicted after Suzanne’s remains were found; James Craig, the Aurora dentist sentenced to life for poisoning his wife; and the disturbing Return to Nature funeral home scandal that left families horrified. Expect true crime deep dives, wild twists, and plenty of paranoid sister banter.